Showing posts with label Vick. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Vick. Show all posts

Monday, September 17, 2007

Ban the Deed, Not the Breed

I’m on a roll tonight.

Apparently, when somebody today punches the “be very afraid” button, Americans turn into total cowards (known in the dog world as “fear biters”). We abandon all discretion, give up our powers of discernment, and nail whatever moves.

As on the wiretapping and war-making fronts, Americans are struggling with our fear factor in the matter of dogs, and here again, panic has set in.

Just as half the country (it seems) supports racial profiling and expelling every undocumented worker in the country, so half supports exiling dogs of so-called “dangerous breeds.” (Bizarrely enough, it may not be the same half.)

That is what happened in Denver, when that city passed a comprehensive ban on dogs known as “pit bulls.” No exceptions and no allowance for the fact that there’s no such breed but several breeds that look kind of like a “pit bull.” If it’s a case of mistaken identity, that’s too bad. Worse still, there was no “grandfather clause” to protect highly socialized family dogs with not so much as a growl on the record. When the ban kicked in, animal control officers ripped all registered “pit bulls” from their owners’ arms, took them away, and in most cases, exterminated them. (Note the irony: Only the dogs of responsible owners are registered with animal control. The problem, however, is with irresponsible owners whose dogs are never registered.)

Anyway, no such thing as innocent until proved guilty for “pit bulls,” and, increasingly, any breed perceived (key word: perceived) to be “inherently dangerous.”

Maybe Michael Vick has done at least one good thing in his sorry life, inadvertently though it may be. His “celebrity” involvement in dog fighting has hiked the “pit bull” into mainstream consciousness and not just as a brute. As an unwitting victim.

Maybe the Vick dogs will get it through the fear-seared brains of breed banners that it’s not the breed, it’s the deed.

Maybe now, anybody with two brain cells to rub together will see that vicious dogs are made. And if they are made, this must mean that they aren’t necessarily born dangerous.

I think there are two reasonable caveats: (1) Dogs from lines bred for fighting are dangerous, regardless of breed. And (2) breeders who can’t document the sound temperament and good health of several generations of their stock should not be patronized. It doesn’t really matter which breed. This is just common sense.

The issue, clearly, isn’t breed. It’s always irresponsible owners, and responsibility begins with the breeder. We already know the drill. Abused children grow up to be abusers. Abused puppies grow up to be dangerous to their families and to others.

Since terms like “backyard breeders” and “puppy mills” are tough to define and seen as code words for partisans in a bigger war, let me put it this way: Responsible breeders test for health and breed for temperament. This is expensive, time-consuming, and sometimes heartbreaking, but it is the cost of doing business for responsible dog breeders.

People who do not test for health (see the diseases common for your breed) and cannot certify the temperament and stability of their dogs back through several generations (temperament generally means situation-appropriate behavior, with emphasis on restraint and non-violence) should not be patronized. Period. Caveat emptor.

Some say that’s not sufficient. Punishing the deed, they say, is too late.

Not in the context of US law, it isn’t, and for good reason. Murder laws punish murderers. In other words, even though we know that there’s a vastly higher incidence of murder among humans than of fatal attacks among dogs, we don’t ban all humans based on that incidence. We “ban” (incarcerate) only the humans who actually commit murder. The approach means that some people are killed, but it also means that innocent people (most of us) aren’t unjustly punished.

It’s a trade-off that civilized people have chosen to make. In my world, the logical parallel is that banning entire breeds is just not something a civilized people chooses to do.

Clearly, the culprit is the irresponsible, cruel, and ignorant dog owner. The incentive for breeding or owning a dog from a dangerous line varies from person to person. Such incentives may sometimes point to probable offenders, and thus to deterrence. Drug dealers want turf protection. Gamblers want bloodlines, champion dogs, and winnings. Ordinary, garden-variety people want protection for threatened residences. Education may work for some of the latter. Patrolling and criminal investigation may work for the former.

Those are the directions to pursue. Educating the public about breeds and their distinct needs, and about what responsible dog ownership entails, is imperative. Subsidizing shelters and spay/neuter clinics, and enlisting the world of dog professionals to help in public education and training and obedience clinics, and branding dog fighting and dog abuse as traits of cowards are the paths that a civilized society could take to address the phenomenon of dangerous dogs.

Friday, September 7, 2007

Thinking About Racism, Again

I'd say most white Americans are sick of hearing about racism.

Unfortunately, those who fall into this category probably don't associate the word where it belongs--with broad and deeply entrenched social and economic systems that divert resources and opportunities from poor communities of color. Instead, they associate it with Tawana Brawley and Al Sharpton--whom I choose to function here as tags for other controversial claimants and spokespersons as well.

Whether she was raped and he was right to defend her, and whether how the case came to function was itself a matter of racism and sexism is not my subject now. The issue for me at this writing is what the Brawley case became, how it functioned to taint everyone it touched, and how it serves now to distract us from fundamental inequities that shame and hurt us all.

To many, this case was the moment Sharpton jumped the shark, and thus it was also the moment that the claim of racism as the cause of a police or judicial injustice to one or more individuals became an "oh for Pete's sake" moment for a lot of white Americans. Today, it's the claim by some that Michael Vick is being railroaded because he's African American that is adding to the inventory of incredible claims of race-based discrimination.

This has a price that I think some in the community's leadership may not have sufficiently considered. Given that as some folks are being turned off by these charges, other folks are being turned on to fight like hell for the alleged victim, energies and focus that are going to controversial individual situations--minor in the great scheme of things--are not going toward remedying expansive and very well-fed systemic travesties. That's too high a price for leaping to defend a dog brutalizer like Michael Vick. There are way more important matters, such as the aftermath of breached levees in New Orleans, and endemic job, credit, income, housing, mortgage, and school inequities that shackle too many decent, working people of color and too many decent, working white people in poverty.

I'm talking partly about how movement emphasesnecessarily lose viability over decades. I'm talking about how words get plumb worn out, and how images and slogans have to be re-charged, re-inspired from time to time. But mostly I'm talking about choosing priorities wisely, and about finding ways to make achieving those priorities "newsworthy" PR events.

The media have a role in putting the emPHAsis on the wrong syLAble, of course. It serves the status quo for our energies to be diverted in this way, just as it serves the status quo for our energies to be diverted from criminal conduct in the executive branch to an endless stream of cases concerning the abduction of pretty white girls or the sexual pecadillos of US senators.

Wouldn't it be better, now, here, in the year 2007, for African American cultural and political leaders, and for the rest of us who believe in equality and justice for all, to concert all these energies and organize all available human and material resources toward publicizing, educating about, and dismantling this instead of defending Michael Vick?

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Michael Vick

Within three years, tops, Vick will be playing again for the NFL. Between then and now, he will go to a lovely retreat in the desert where he'll emerge rehabbed as a member of PETA's board of directors, marry a nice lady veterinarian, and take up dog rescue as a community service. He will appear on Larry King and blabber about his misguided youth and the racists that declared him guilty before his trial, and his new-found sensitivity, and he won't be sporting dreds.

In the meantime, it appears that our rush to judgment was right, after all. People reached the only sane conclusion possible, based on the evidence in the media. What made our conclusion not a collective racist spasm was the deed and the videos, duh.

Georgia's NAACP would do well to issue a revised statement on the Vick sitch, because, excuse me, rote defense--let me repeat that: rote defense--of any popular, wealthy African American athlete regardless of circumstance and evidence (does the name O.J. ring a bell?) does diddly squat to enhance our collective sensibilities about justice, diversity, and personal integrity. It stinks of special pleading, undermines the credibility of the NAACP when it does confront genuine racism, and adds to what I fear is a building store of resentment among many white Americans about an overplayed card.

If he should be diagnosed as a bona fide sociopath--and it's not out of the question--Vick's actions would be more comprehensible but not excusable. He has no excuses. He knows what cruelty means, but he chose to make it a business proposition just the same. His macho quotient evidently insufficiently demonstrated on the football field, he chose to torment dogs to prove how tough he really is.

Vick sure isn't the first guy to equate abuse with manliness, and that's the rest of the discussion we should be having about this matter. Yes, I'm encouraged that it has shed some light on the truth about dog fighting and "pit bulls"--vicious dogs are made by vicious people, not born with a breed imprint--but I hope that, in addition to a special on the spectacular nastiness of dog fighting, we will soon see a CNN special on the connections between men who abuse their dogs and men who abuse their wifes and lovers, because it's unquestionably there. Such a documentary would add significantly to the good that could come out of this hideous episode, but no, I'm not holding my breath.

One last thing: Dog fighting isn't a southern disease, and I'm sick of hearing that it is, so siddown, shuddup, and get a clue. It exists worldwide, and it exists in every US quadrant, social milieu, and demographic. But it's illegal, so it's hidden. Like bootlegging, usually the poor people do it and the rich people get the thrills. (In this case, the rich man did it and got the thrills.) Stop with the specious projections, please, and look at the facts. Recently it was reported that one in five of every Chicago school kids has witnessed dog fighting. Google on Chicago dog fighting. If you think it's a southern thing, you'll definitely be surprised.

Let's put this virulent regional chauvinism out with the rest of the trash.